shobogan:
Every time someone talks about how BQM loves and respects Steph I just have to stare at them.
No. No, I really don’t think he does.
If he did, he wouldn’t dismiss and demean her history as a vigilante. He wouldn’t whitewash her past. He wouldn’t carelessly excise her brutality and ruthlessness and anger. He wouldn’t ignore her skills and experience. He wouldn’t abandon her ties not only to her best friend, but to her mentors.
He would write Stephanie Brown. Not a watered down substitute he finds more palatable, who fits more neatly into the boxes he wants to present.
It’s a shame that his depiction of Steph as Batgirl is the only one we’re going to get.
I will never get over how poorly BQM wrote not only Steph, but also her relationships with other vigilantes, particularly Cass (or the… lack of writing that relationship) and with Barbara. Babs was the one who stuck up for Steph after Bruce fired her as Robin and made him admit that he’d been unfair. Steph knew who Oracle was before she knew Tim’s name. Babs, and the Birds, were there for Steph, often when the core Batfam was shunning her.
I hate that BQM ignored everything that Steph achieved during her time as Spoiler and Robin. That he made Batgirl the “first thing she saw through”, that he made Batgirl the first time she was “doing this for the right reasons”, like she hadn’t come to that point within a few months of her vigilante career, when she stuck around during the quake to help people, when she realized that the suburbs needed superheroes too.
It’s like he just ticked “bubbly blonde” boxes for personality and didn’t reallylookat Steph. BQM’s Steph isn’t the Steph that nearly killed Zsasz because she’d just seen his last victim, she isn’t the Steph that tried to strangle her dad, who had to be stopped from beating the Penguin to a pulp, who stormed out of a diner because she couldn’t stand to listen to people spouting rape culture bullshit. And I loved that Steph, the one who wasn’t perfect, who was angry and a little ruthless because she’d been hurt by the world and sometimes just wanted to hurt it back.
In the end, to me, it can be summed up by that one damn little panel where BQM made Steph a Blue Lantern.
Because he’s wrong.
Steph isn’t about hope. Stephloseshope. Sometimes she loses hope because the world is so screwed up that sending a few bad guys to jail isn’t going to change anything. She sees a system that failed her, that fails hundred of other people, including little kids, and she feels hopeless.
But that doesn’t mean she’s going to stop fighting. It isn’t about hope, it’s about doing something in the face of hopelessness. Steph picks herself up even if she knows she’s going to lose again, simply because she refuses to stay down. If Steph were a Lantern, she’d be Green, and BQM just didn’t understand that.
Some really good discussion.